St. James City Homes For Sale — 86 properties in St. James City, FL Luxury Real Estate

Galt Island: Galt Island, a private 36 acre barrier island, is located within the Pine Island Sound Aquatic Preserve. There is unrestricted, open water access to the Gulf of Mexico, a true fisherman's paradise! Unbelievable open water flats fishing, deep water channels, spectacular sunsets, and breathtaking views of Mackeever Keys, the JN Ding Darling National Wildlife Refuge and Sanibel Island, Captiva Island, North Captiva Island, and Caya Costa Island. There are only fifteen home sites located on the Island's South and West shorelines (a total of 11 acres.) Thirteen homes are currently built, with one under construction, and one lot owned (not for sale). A one mile private paved causeway connects Galt Island to Pine Island. Galt Island also has 25 acre Calusa Indian Preserve (The Shell Indians) located on it, never to be built upon. These are known as the Galt Island Archaeology Digs. Each property owner owns 1/ 15th of the causeway and preserve.

Galt Island: Rare private gated island community estate home connected by private causeway to mainland. MILES-WIDE water views from all 3 floors of Pine Island Sound, Sanibel, Captiva, Useppa, and many mangrove islands. 5 bedrooms plus other rooms now used as dens/offices could be guest quarters if desired. Private Owner Quarters on 3rd floor include master suite, office, living rm, den, and large kitchen. Separate Guest Quarters on 2nd floor w/3 bedrms+ den, 2 baths. 1st floor includes guest kitchen, guest bath, workshop, "basement storage", RV garage, and 3-car garage with a 4th bay now used as workshop that could be vehicle storage. Unobstructed views even from kitchen with glass windows under cabinets. Beautifully landscaped. Dock includes 2 slips with lifts. Huge pool & spa overlook fantastic water views. Multiple balconies on front and rear of home. There's even a waterfall and pond. RV garage nearly 47' long w/16' door can handle the biggest motor home. Custom designed for max enjoyment and privacy. Built on concrete pilings driven 19' into ground to insure stability. Community includes 13 acres of Preserve/Calusa Indian Mounds. Words cannot describe the attention to detail.

Pine Island: Imagine, being immersed in stunning views of the intracoastal from every aspect of this 4,284 sq ft, 5 bedroom, 4 bathroom island sanctuary. The space features a gourmet kitchen with a Thermador propane cooktop, chefs refrigerator/freezer, instant hot tap, wine cooler, walk-in pantry, large office space with custom built-ins, a large second floor loft area with murphy bed, and third-floor screened covered rooftop terrace ideal for taking in those stunning views and Florida sunsets. This home accentuates an extraordinary outdoor space featuring a gazebo granting up close access to marine life, 2 covered boat lifts (13,000# & 5000#) with space for a third, over 350 ft of seawall, and a large pool complete with sun-shelf, water features and a spa. This exceptional single family home is occupied on one of Pine Island’s largest lots. The 3+ detached car garage is air conditioned and solar system. This is your ideal serenity space less then 1 minute to direct gulf access, the famous beaches of Sanibel, Captiva and Cayo Costa. There is just too much to mention. You need to come see this for yourself!

Pine Island Shores Unit 2: Seaside living at it’s best. This stunning 3/4 bedroom, 4.5 bath home is one of Pine Island’s most outstanding properties. Uniquely coupling modern, contemporary, & eccentric design elements this 3-story 4,350 square foot home is simply magnificent. Located directly on Pine Island Sound, upon entering you are immediately drawn to the absolute tranquility of the views overlooking the intracoastal & Ding Darling Preserve of Sanibel. The open contemporary floor plan features a dramatic entryway w/ sweeping staircase, custom ship railing, designers dream kitchen & elevator. The master suite features every couples ideal set-up a his & hers bathroom-yes, you read that correct. The first level is occupied by the 3+ car-garage w/ workshop, heated sparkling pool, hot tub & and outdoor shower. A large glass walled cigar bar complete w/ a high capacity air handler encompasses the top level while merging the junior on-suites together. Concrete construction provides a secure foundation w/ triple AC for zone efficiency. This home couples seaside and island living. Also available is a lot just steps away from the home, that has 2 covered boat lifts & offers deep water protected gulf access

Bayview Acres: Unique Opportunity for purchase this fabulous Bayfront 3/2.5 pool home with plenty of storage, and upgrades galore, and your own private island! The air conditioned garage with epoxy floor can easily hold 4 cars. There are 2 boat lifts, one covered at 16K# and the 2nd, at 12K#. Do you enjoy entertaining? Then the aluminum frame 17’ x 27’ bamboo pattern tiki will make you the envy of all your friends. Do you need a place to store your RV, boat trailer, etc., well, there is a 64’ pavered open storage area to park your extra toys. The boat lift cover was replaced in Nov. 2018. The entire attic has spray foam and even has an air conditioning vent. The attic stays cool all year round, making your electric bill very reasonable. The entry, kitchen/great room open plan has unobstructed views of San Carlos Bay and overlooks the pool and low maintenance back yard. Enjoy the sunroom looking out over the pool and low maintenance back yard. The island behind the home keeps the choppy water from disturbing your boats and docks of all composite decking. There are hurricane shutters all around, so you can leave and not worry about your home. You must see in person to truly appreciate!

Pine Island Shores Unit 2: Southern Exposure Gem on Pine Island! This exquisite and unique home is located on the southernmost point of Pine Island, just across the bay from Sanibel and Captiva Islands. Architecturally solid concrete construction provides a secure foundation against the elements as you enjoy breathtaking views from every level. The lower level boasts a 3 ½ car garage, nautical bar, and home office. Sliding glass doors lead to the expansive patio and a full-size volleyball court. The main level has a spacious Great Room for entertaining with beautiful marble and coral shellstone flooring and loads of natural light. This rare gem features a large rooftop observation deck, a shuffleboard court, a boat dock with a 13,000 lb lift and 111ft of Bay frontage. Surrounded by southwest Florida’s best beaches including Fort Myers Beach, Sanibel Island, Captiva and world class fishing at Boca Grande pass, you’ll never have to wander far from home to enjoy the best that Southwest Florida has to offer. Truly a one-of-a-kind masterpiece.

St James City: This gorgeous island estate is a must see! Situated on .62 acres with 187ft of beautiful bay front property the views from this home are absolutely stunning! From the the second you pull in to the driveway you know you are going to experience something truly unique. As you walk into the property through the custom copper gate, the tone is immediately set with the peaceful sound of water cascading down the custom fountain feature. Each tile on the fountain is hand sculpted making it the centerpiece of the courtyard, perfect for entertaining. As you walk through the front door the peaceful feeling continues when you are met with the wide open living space, great natural light and unobstructed breathtaking views. The gourmet kitchen is a chef's dream complete with gas stove, French door wall oven, GE Advantium speed oven, Sub Zero fridge/freezer, wine cooler and ample countertop work space. Throughout the home are custom handmade tiles that offer a one of a kind atheistic touch. The rear of this home offers a beautiful saltwater pool, sundeck, covered patio and a huge yard. The separate workshop could easily be converted into a private guest home. Come experience this private estate

Pine Island Shores Unit 2: One of the most premier properties with big water views of San Carlos Bay, Pine Island Sound and Sanibel Island. 170 feet of deep water, reinforced seawall, protected canal with covered 10,000 lb. remote lift and a metal roof covered slip. Trex dock boards, water, electric, fish cleaning stand and shower on dock. Professionally landscaped and paver paths through beautiful gardens, paver driveway, salt water, self cleaning, heated pool surrounded by large paver deck. Easy kayak launch from a private, protected sandy slope. Now... step inside this open, light filled home with soaring ceilings and water views from every window. This home has been remodeled in 2018/ 2019 with all impact windows and doors, high end A/C, electric panel, piping, hot water, all Profile smart appliances connectable to your phone, granite kitchen, marble tiled backsplash, custom plantation shutters, remote controlled shades in family room, remote controlled hurricane shutters on lanai. The lot was filled to increase the elevation while retaining views.

Bayview Acres: Masterful design and modern luxury are uniquely embodied in this St James City waterfront masterpiece. Enjoy the feeling of home while living in a tropical dream only minutes to Pine Island Sound, Sanibel/Captiva Island and beyond to the Gulf of Mexico. This one-of-a-kind three level home offers luxurious, but approachable, finishing touches you've always dreamt of. Offered fully furnished with new and tasteful furnishings and decor. With grand staircases leading to each level, wood flooring in most common areas, a warm and inviting main living room complete with sweeping water views and a gas fireplace. There are balconies on each level, multiple bedrooms and bonus rooms for extra guests if you please. A large master suite encompasses the top level. There is also a 3 car garage, one is detached from the home and provides additional space currently used as the boat house/game room. The lower level offers a kitchenette, separate living room, bedroom, bathroom and private entrance. On the exterior of the home, there is lovely low-maintenance landscaping, irrigation, and a wooden boat dock complete with covered 10klbs boat lift. This is the perfect home to live your island dream!

Bayview Acres: This exceptional new waterfront home will impress you with high-end design, water views and resort-style pool, and unparalleled construction. This home was built utilizing the most sought after materials for disaster mitigation. The entire home was constructed with disaster resistant ICF steel reinforced and poured concrete walls which is the same construction used on the only home standing on Mexico City Beach, FL after Hurricane Michael. High impact windows and doors and the metal roof is Miami-Dade hurricane rated. The second floor is sided with CELECT synthetic siding which will not warp or rot. The second floor deck and boat dock utilize synthetic lumber designed for longevity. Porcelain tile floors through most areas with marble in the master bath and pool deck. Chef’s kitchen with high-end cabinets, granite, island, gas stove and stainless appliances. Split bedroom floor plan, master bedroom with spa-like en suite, elevator, and laundry. Ground floor has an a/c storage room and “Mermaid” bathroom. Open air saltwater, gas heated pool and spa, and 4K lbs and 13K lbs covered lifts. 3 car garage with area for fitness and workshop. Located minutes to the Sound and beyond.

Pine Island Shores Unit 11: REDUCED! ONLY $291.85 Per Sq'. One of a kind, located on Macadamia St. 3/2 + 1/1 guest apt. with 3rd floor private master en-suite, recently remodeled. It includes a massive all glass walk-in shower and a jaccuzzi tub. The open living area has 24' ceilings, a fireplace and a custom entertainment wall. The gourmet cook's kitchen has a Dacor gas cooktop in the Ceasarstone island. Stainless steel appliances were replaced recently. There are 3 new A/C units and 2 new hot water heaters. The massive pool has a hot tub and a water sheer. Travertine tile covers the entire outdoor entertainment area. The outdoor kitchen has a massive granite bar. There are 2 large commercial grills for cooking your favorite meals! Automatic insect misters are installed to keep you comfortable while enjoying the beautiful open water sunsets and sunrises viewed from the many decks! There are automatic shades outside and inside to block out the brightess sunshine! At your dock there are 2 covered boat lifts- a 12,000# & 7,500#. The outside elevator/lift will take you and or your groceries from the ground floor to the main living area. There is so much more to this home, so you have to come see it for yourself!

Sandpiper Point: Imagine sitting on the front deck, drink of choice in hand, and enjoying the stunning view of the Intracoastal Waterway, Sanibel, Ft. Myers Beach, all the way to the Gulf of Mexico in this gated waterfront community! First floor includes a 4 car garage with plenty of storage for your cars, boats, and trailers, a workout room, and a workshop. You can take the elevator to the 2nd floor with a large kitchen, living/dining area, 2 bedrooms and a bath, and then all the way to the 3rd floor with the master bedroom, master bath, and laundry room. You will find the views amazing on the wrap around outside second floor balcony. A beautiful heated pool and spa in a fully screened in lanai awaits you for a relaxing swim. A very large captains deck dock with a large boat lift awaits you boat. Very few homes on Pine Island enjoy a better view and having the good fortune to be snuggled in a gated, secure neighborhood.

Sandpiper Point: Live your dream life in this stunning custom built 2014, deep water direct gulf access home in the gated community of Sandpiper Point which is minutes away from Pine Island Sound & the Intercoastal waterway allowing for easy navigation to the famous beaches of Sanibel, Captiva, Cayo Costa & Boca Grande. Entertaining will be a breeze w/ this spacious open floor plan & gourmet kitchen, Ruffino custom solid wood cabinetry, granite countertops, Thermador gas cooktop & top of line Kitchen Aid stainless steel appliances. Master suite is located on the first floor & features large pocket sliders that open to the spacious lanai. Pristine polished travertine tile throughout the first floor & hard wood throughout the second floor which features 2 ample guest bedrooms w/ sliders that open to a private spacious balcony. The rooftop balcony offers expansive views of the Gulf of Mexico, canals & preserve. Relax in the heated pool/spa. Enjoy boating & fishing w/ a 10K# covered boat lift w/ water and electric at the dock. House is constructed with Insulated Concrete Form (ICF), has all impact glass windows & doors. Too many amenities to list This is a Must See!

Pine Island Shores Unit 2: COASTAL LIVING AT IT'S BEST! Located just minutes to the Intracoastal and a quick boat ride to the Gulf beaches and some of the best fishing in SW Florida. You will fall in love with this custom built 3 bedroom 2 bathroom waterfront home the moment you walk through the door. All the furniture and artwork are included! Tastefully decorated with a beachy, whimsical design, just move right in and start enjoying island life! Open floor plan with AMAZING views of Pine Island Sound and Sanibel Island. Pocket sliding glass doors open out to the screened lanai with stunning views of the bay, a perfect spot to relax and watch the boats go by in the Intracoastal! The beautiful kitchen features Cambria Quartz countertops, GE high profile stainless steel appliances, and soft close cabinets. Metal roof, hurricane impact windows & doors, 4x8 plank tile flooring throughout, plantation shutters, and crown molding. Enjoy the warm Florida days lounging by the heated salt water pool w/covered dining and sitting area, a great place to entertain and watch dolphins and manatees play in the canal. There are 2 covered boat lifts, one 14000# & one 7500#, composite docks & fish cleaning station.

Bayview Acres: TROPICAL PARADISE in ST. James City. Waterfront pool home with spectacular features located in the most beautiful location on the island! It's 5 o'clock every day complete with your own waterfront tiki hut perfect for entertaining and a front row seat for famous SW Florida sunsets! Your spacious lanai is home to many pool parties or gives you a secluded place to relax in the sun. Your backyard is a lush sanctuary with gorgeous tropical flora and fauna. You also have a 10K lbs covered boat lift, wrap around dock within a small lagoon area offering privacy and protection. Just beyond the mangroves is Pine Island Sound where you are minutes from Sanibel/Captiva Island, Fort Myers Beach, the Gulf of Mexico and just a short boat ride to Boca Grande. This home offers an open concept with sweeping views of the water and your yard. The wood plank ceramic tile throughout the home gives natural light and a bright crisp appearance. Oversized kitchen, baths, and master suite are updated. Exterior features include: metal roof, folding hurricane shutters throughout, paver driveway and beautiful pergolas. There is also a bonus room off the lanai! Your Florida coastal dream home is right here.

Sandpiper Point: This lovely home sits in one of the most desirable gated neighborhoods on Pine Island on an over .25 acre lot. It has quick access to the Intracoastal Waterway and the Gulf of Mexico from the covered boat lift and dock along the canal. The construction boasts concrete pilings and tie beams, elevator from the garage/ground level to the 3rd floor, 3BR+Study, 3Ba, large open deck on the 2nd level and a screened porch on the 3rd level off of the main living room and master bedroom, overlooking San Carlos Bay & Sanibel. The left side of the garage is approximately 36’ deep, so you can store a boat/trailer or the possibility of storing 2 cars, and a 3rd car on the right side.. There’s plenty of storage throughout this home. There is also plenty of room for a pool if you want, on the north or east side. The roof was replaced in fall of 2017. There are also amazing 360 degree views from the rooftop deck, not to mention the 4th of July fireworks from Sanibel! Make your appointment today so you can be enjoying the warm tropical breezes and the quick access to the Gulf of Mexico and the Outer Islands and beaches that Pine Island offers!

Gulfhaven: KEY WEST STYLE STUNNER! This custom, one owner luxury waterfront home will take your breath away! This Gulf access home is located minutes by boat to Pine Island Sound, and all that SW Florida is famous for! This three-story stilt home has a fantastic floor plan, sweeping views from every level, tile throughout, custom cypress ceilings, Brazilian oak front doors with custom carved glass and a designer kitchen. Home features above-standard construction, newer hurricane impact windows (2017), Hardie board exterior, top of the line decking and metal roof. This home also offers the convenience of having all bedrooms on the main level, workshop/utility room, bonus room, extra bathroom and storage on the ground level and an interior elevator! The top level of the home is the perfect place for a game/entertainment room, with a kitchenette, bathroom and amazing views. There is ample parking under the home. There are also (2) boat lifts, one is covered 10k lbs, the smaller lift is 4k lbs. Beautiful dockage nestled among the mangroves with water, electric and fish cleaning station. The yard is a tropical wonderland with mango trees, banana trees, citrus and more. Welcome to your new home!

Bayview Acres: Saint James -Bay Front -Vintage Home on a Premium Lot with South Facing Bay Views! A 50' X 4' dock with 8,000 lb. lift. Existing house is very original but in excellent condition and features 2-bedroom, 2-bath, 3-car garage and indoor laundry room, plus an over-sized screened lanai. The perfect lot to build your Island dream home or enjoy this charming affordable Bay Front Water Getaway!

Pine Island: Boaters Paradise!! Come relax and enjoy this beautifully remodeled home overlooking the water. You will love the new pool, hot tub and outdoor kitchen and private heated pool! This home offers two bedrooms with queen size beds in each room and a large loft with two full size beds. In the main living area you will enjoy the view of the water and a spacious kitchen. This home is perfect for hosting family and friends as it offers a separate downstairs 1 Bedroom 1 Bath apartment with a pullout sofa in the living room sleeping 4. Attention boaters there is a Boat lift and is only five minutes to open water! This home is being sold fully furnished!! Don't miss out on your very own piece of paradise!!

Pine Island Shores Unit 5: BOATER'S DELIGHT! Quick Direct access!!! Stunning 2 story home with inground pool/spa only minutes to the Intercoastal/Gulf is now available! This key west style home features a gourmet kitchen with Viking stainless steel gas stove and other appliances, stainless and custom wood countertops and huge breakfast bar - perfect for entertaining. Bamboo floors make the first floor ultra chic! You will enjoy the gorgeous views overlooking the newer salt water heated pool and spa (2015), salt water canal where the dolphins frolic, and your private boat dock with lift! The master bedroom has a walk in closet and a large sitting area (possible uses are office, nursery, exercise area) Newer windows have been installed except in the breakfast area. Enjoy countless hours of entertainment in the great Florida outdoors in your very own Tiki Hut with outdoor kitchen and bar area! Water and electric are at the dock. Back yard is fenced. Seawall was redone in 2015. Home has been used as a seasonal rental when the owner is not using it and offers rental income! Only minutes to fun dining and shops of St. James City.